• The Brandshift
  • Posts
  • Old Spice’s “The Man Your Man Could Smell Like”The “Brand Consistency Challenge”

Old Spice’s “The Man Your Man Could Smell Like”The “Brand Consistency Challenge”

The “Brand Consistency Challenge”

Welcome, Growth enthusiasts.

🎨 As Reid Hoffman famously said:

"If you're not embarrassed by the first version of your product, you’ve launched too late."

Reid Hoffman


Hoffman highlights the importance of quick iteration in startups. Early products don’t have to be perfect; what matters is getting feedback and improving rapidly.

In today’s Shift:

Read time: 3 minutes

🧠 Today’s Growth Insight

Growth Experiment: The “Brand Consistency Challenge”
Objective: Ensure your branding across all channels (website, social media, emails) is consistent in tone, design, and messaging.

Steps to Try:

  1. Audit your branding: Review your website, social channels, and email templates. Look for mismatches in color, tone, or message. (Does your LinkedIn feel corporate while your Instagram feels like a party?)

  2. Create a style guide: Ensure you’ve got a one-stop doc outlining fonts, colors, voice, and tone.

  3. Align your assets: Update content to match your brand guidelines. Ensure that your posts, emails, and landing pages all feel like they belong to the same family.

  4. Track engagement: See if more consistency results in better engagement or a stronger brand recall.

Expected Outcome: A seamless brand experience across all touchpoints, leading to higher brand recognition and loyalty.

Humorous Disclaimer: This experiment may result in spontaneous branding epiphanies, followed by an urgent need to overhaul your entire color scheme at 2 AM.

⚡ Marketing Power-ups

Campaign Highlight: Old Spice’s “The Man Your Man Could Smell Like”
Old Spice took a dying brand and gave it a hyper-masculine yet completely absurd twist. The campaign combined humor, over-the-top visuals, and a talking horse to generate viral content that resonated with men and women alike. The ad's unpredictability kept viewers hooked and turned the once-forgotten brand into a cultural phenomenon.

Why it Worked: It nailed the C’s of branding—Clarity, Character, and Connection. They knew their message (“Be manly”), used a distinctive voice, and formed an emotional (albeit comedic) connection with viewers.

Replicate This: Create memorable content by exaggerating your brand’s personality. Lean into your brand’s quirks, make people laugh, and they’ll remember you.

Witty Comment: If your brand isn't bold enough to have a guy on a horse, start small—maybe a goldfish in a bowl?

⛏️ The Ad Breakdown: Impactful B2B ads, explained.

Hand-picked Meta & LinkedIn ads for design & copy inspiration

📈 Data-Driven Insights

Statistic: According to Forbes, brands that are consistently represented across all platforms see a 23% increase in revenue.
Implications: Maintaining consistency across platforms makes your brand more trustworthy and memorable. Startups that manage to maintain this consistency in tone, visual identity, and messaging will not only boost recognition but also revenue.

Pro Tip: Don’t just slap your logo everywhere and call it consistency. Ensure your messaging and tone are on-brand from tweets to customer emails. If you’re friendly and casual on social, don’t suddenly sound like a lawyer in your emails.

Humorous Note: Branding consistency: It’s like keeping up a gym routine, hard to stick with but totally worth it when your muscles (or revenue) start showing up.

🔧 Tools & Resources Spotlight

Top 3 Tools for Growth (from Product Hunt)

  1. Upbeat – Turns your content into bite-sized social media posts in seconds. Perfect for keeping your brand messaging clear and concise across channels.

  2. Curator – This tool helps you organize and present your brand visuals for inspiration or client pitches. Consistency starts with a well-planned vision board.

  3. Headline Studio – Helps you craft perfect headlines for social posts, blogs, or newsletters. Headlines that fit your brand voice keep engagement high.

Humorous Comment: These tools will save you time, just don’t spend it all perfecting your Pinterest board, okay?

👥 Community Voices

Problem: “My startup’s brand feels disconnected across platforms. How can I create a cohesive identity?”
Solution: Start with the 5 C’s of Branding:

  • Clarity: Be clear on what your brand stands for.

  • Consistency: Audit your messaging across platforms and align everything.

  • Character: Inject your brand’s personality into everything you create.

  • Connection: Build emotional connections with your audience by being authentic.

  • Creativity: Don’t be afraid to stand out and take risks.

Humorous Observation: Finding your brand's “personality” is like trying to pick a favorite Taylor Swift album—you’ll change your mind at least five times before you settle on the right one.

📚 3 Must-Read Articles:

  1. The Psychology of Branding
    Takeaway: Branding isn’t just about logos—it’s about triggering the right emotions. Learn how to use psychology to build a brand that sticks.

  2. How to Build a Brand Identity from Scratch
    Takeaway: A step-by-step guide to creating a brand that resonates, including templates for brand boards and style guides.

  3. The Future of Branding in 2025
    Takeaway: Stay ahead of trends—learn how AI, AR, and personalization will shape branding strategies in the near future.

Humorous Note: Reading these may lead to a sudden urge to spend the rest of the day obsessing over font pairings and hex codes.

💡 Founder Spotlight

Founder: Sarah Jennings, Creator of “BiteBox”
Sarah Jennings built BiteBox, a snack subscription service, from scratch. Her branding journey involved creating a “fun and friendly” voice that connected with health-conscious millennials. Instead of positioning BiteBox as another “serious health company,” she built a playful brand that felt more like your snack-obsessed best friend.

Growth Strategies: She used consistent messaging across all touchpoints—Instagram, email newsletters, and even the unboxing experience—to build a loyal customer base.

Inspiring Quote: “People come for the snacks, but they stay for the puns.”

Funny Quote: “I spent six hours once debating if the right orange was ‘too orange.’ Spoiler alert: It was.”

🔄 Trend Watch

Trend: Micro-Influencers and Nano-Influencers
Brands are increasingly working with smaller influencers (micro- and nano-) instead of big-name celebrities. These influencers tend to have smaller but more engaged audiences, making them great for building authentic connections.

Impact: Startups can get high engagement without the massive budget needed for celebrity endorsements. Micro-influencers can help startups appear more relatable and trustworthy.

Practical Advice: Find influencers who genuinely love your product and align with your brand’s voice. Authentic partnerships lead to more authentic engagement.

Humorous Prediction: Soon, even your neighbor’s cat with 1,200 followers will be influencing product choices.

🛠 DIY Growth Experiments

Experiment: The “Color Consistency Test”
Objective: Test how color consistency impacts user engagement on your website and social media.

Steps:

  1. Pick a color palette aligned with your brand and apply it across your homepage, social channels, and email templates.

  2. Monitor engagement: Track likes, shares, and clicks. Are users responding better when your visuals are cohesive?

  3. A/B Test different color schemes to see which gets better engagement.

Expected Outcome: A stronger visual identity and improved engagement.

Humorous Disclaimer: Careful: You may suddenly develop opinions on shades of blue you didn’t even know existed!